Content Comparison

JIRA reference:  FT-519, FT-520

Overview

This process applies when there's a negative at any of the committees and after the applicant has reviewed and/or provided a rebuttal. The applicant will click the "Continue Review" button and s/he will be prompted with the questions below depending on the application type.

Requirements

Tenure Only, Promotion Only, Tenure w/ Automatic Promotion types

Questions to ask the applicant after reviewing recommendations and providing a rebuttal

• I submitted a rebuttal
• I did not submit a rebuttal

Tenure and Promotion Application Type

• Known:
  • Requires 2 sets of votes and recommendations - one for Tenure and the other for promotion
  • Only 1 report uploaded by the chair
• Assumptions
  create a modal for the applicant on the yes for Tenure and the no for Promotion
  • There was a negative recommendation at one of the committee levels for Tenure and/or Promotion
  • Table below outlines what to do based on the TRPC's recommendations, i.e. we don't care what the DPC,DC,Dean recommendations are
  • Questions to ask the applicant after reviewing recommendations and providing a rebuttal
    • I submitted a rebuttal to tenure (will be sent to the Chancellor/Provost)
    • I submitted a rebuttal to promotion (will be sent to the TPRC)
    • I submitted a rebuttal to both (will be sent to the TPRC)

  I did not submit a rebuttal to either (will be sent to the Chancellor/Provost)

  
  

  TPRC

  ...

  Applicant
  Tenure Recommendation	Promotion Recommendation	Rebut the Tenure	Rebut the Promotion

  ...

  	Transition To
  yes	yes	yes or no	yes or no	Chancellor/Provost
  yes	no	yes	yes	TPRC redux

  ...

  yes	no	yes	no	Chancellor/Provost

  ...

  yes	no	no	yes	TPRC redux
  yes

  ...

  no	no	no	Chancellor/Provost
  no

  ...

  	yes**	yes	yes	TRPC redux
  no	yes**	yes	no	TRPC redux
  no	yes

  ...

  **	no	yes	TRPC redux
  no	yes**	no	no	Chancellor/Provost
  no	no	yes	yes	TPRC redux
  no	no

  ...

  yes

  no

  TRPC redux

  ...

  no	no	no	yes	TPRC redux
  no	no	no	no

  ...

  Chancellor/Provost

  ** should never happen because you can't get a promotion without being tenured